3-piece shakers are easily recognizable by their cap and built-in strainer. They are widely used and appreciated by cocktail enthusiasts, as well as some professionals, for their ease of use. And very often, these 3-piece shakers are called “Cobbler shakers.” Here is why this could be considered a mistake.


Why the Word “Cobbler”?

The term “Cobbler” refers to a family of cocktails made with a base alcohol, sugar, and fruit.

At the origin of this cocktail family is a major classic: the Sherry Cobbler. One of the earliest references to the Sherry Cobbler appears in the September 6, 1838, issue of the New York Morning Herald, which mentioned a “brandy and sherry cobbler” made by a certain Payne of Park Row.


Jerry Thomas and the Sherry Cobbler

When Jerry Thomas, the father of mixology, published the Sherry Cobbler recipe in his 1862 book Bartenders Guide, the recipe was prepared and standardized as follows:

To make a Sherry Cobbler, the sherry, sugar, and orange slices were shaken together, then the drink was garnished with berries. I would also like to add a small clarification: in the 1887 edition of Jerry Thomas's book, two small pieces of pineapple were added to the recipe and shaken together with the other ingredients.


Cobblers in the 1880s

Although there is no evidence to suggest that Jerry Thomas used a mixing tin—he likely stirred the ingredients with a spoon—I have nonetheless managed to uncover some highly relevant illustrations showing the preparation of "cobblers" dating back to the 1880s.

These illustrations come from American and Other Drinks, written by Charlie Paul, a bartender who had worked in New York, Paris, and at London’s Royal Aquarium, among other places.

 Charlie Paul making a cobbler cocktail in 1884

Illustration of cobbler shakers by Charlie Paul in 1884


So Why Shouldn't a 3-Piece Shaker Be Called a “Cobbler Shaker”?

There are three main reasons, and they are quite significant, why a 3-piece shaker should not be called a “Cobbler shaker”:

  1. The 3-piece shaker did not exist during the period when Cobblers were being made, so it could not have been used to prepare them.
  2. The Sherry Cobbler was never strained. It was prepared directly in the glass or shaken using a simple mixing tin.
  3. A "cobbler shaker" was, quite simply, a Boston shaker.

A 3-piece shaker should therefore simply be called a 3-piece shaker, rather than a “Cobbler shaker”.

Personally, my instructions for making a Sherry Cobbler these days are the same as Charlie Paul’s: shake the ingredients and fruit with crushed ice in a Boston shaker, then pour the entire contents into a glass.